CHAPTER ONE
Key West, Florida
Fifteen-year-old Finch Delaney stood frozen in the door of a murky Key West bar, her mother’s voice in her mind, admonishing her for lurking alone in dark corners. But her mother was dead, and Finch really needed to work up the courage to step inside. Three hours ago, as she walked home from school, she couldn’t have imagined saying this. But she needed her brother’s help.
She’d spent two hours tracking him down, and finally—here he was, only thirty feet away. Belting out a sea shanty on a rickety wooden stage, waving a pint glass around, little drops of lager adding to the pub’s preexisting layers of grime. Finch could smell the room from here: musty, sour, fermented. The humid bar air stuck to her skin like taffy, a cloud of evaporating perspiration from the rabble of sweaty drunk men inside.
“Oh, the wind was foul and the sea ran high,” sang Les, blustery and cocky as ever.
“Leave her, Johnny, leave her,” the men at the bar sang plaintively in response. They were almost all men. Finch spotted one butch lady in the corner, who simultaneously annoyed Finch with her audacity and inspired Finch to be a little more like… that.
But instead, Finch shirked into the wooden door frame. She’d wait for Les to finish the song and exit the stage, so there wouldn’t be a literal spotlight on them when she darted inside and grabbed him, like the quiet little gremlin she was.
But then Les spotted her. Onstage, he jolted, beer spraying like fireworks. His face lit up like he hadn’t even considered that his little sister lurking in a bar uninvited could be a sign of a problem. He put his pint glass down on the stage and pointed to her, framed in the doorway. Every burly man at the bar seemed to turn around in unison to look at her. She felt overwhelmingly dizzy and grabbed the door to stabilize herself.
“Hey, that’s my sister!” shouted Les, slurring a little. “Get that kid in here to do the clapping bit of ‘Wild Rover.’ She’s known it since she was three.”
Finch shook her head furiously.
“Kids can’t come in bars, Delaney,” someone shouted at him from a bar stool.
“Oh, sure she can,” said Les, who darted over to Finch and was now tugging her on stage.
Finch dug her heels in as he pulled her towards the stage and hissed, “Les, stop. Les, I hate the clapping bit. Les!”
“You love clapping, Finchy!” said Les.
“I had a phase when I was a toddler, yes,” said Finch. She tried to jump off the little stage but he grabbed her arm again. She tried to meet his eyes, but they were frenetic. “I need to talk to you. It’s important.”
But Les’s beer had clearly given him selective hearing. He took a deep breath, about to launch into another song, when the bartender looked up, noticed what was happening, and banged his fist on the wooden bar top. “OUT,” he shouted.
“Just let her do the damn clapping, you salty cretin,” slurred Les.
Finch locked eyes with the bartender and shook her head.
He nodded at her subtly. “Out, Captain. Or you don’t lead shanties for two weeks.”
Les held his hands up in a truce posture. “Okay, okay. We’re going,” he said, dragging his feet disagreeably off the stage. She followed him, averting her gaze from the crowd. She presumed she was the only one who heard him add, “You soggy bilge rat,” in the direction of the bartender.
Les downed the rest of his pint and slammed the glass down a smidgen too hard on the bar top and then saluted the room. Finch followed him to the door as quickly as she could manage it.
They both stepped out into the humid evening, pausing on the sidewalk below a streetlamp. Tipsy Les immediately launched into another rant. He’d always had strong opinions. “I mean, c’mon. There’s the letter of the law and then there’s the spirit of—”
“—Connie’s gone.” Finch struggled to say it loudly enough to cut off his impassioned diatribe.
He froze and scrutinized her face under the streetlight. Clearly caught off guard, he stumbled over his words for a moment. Something almost unprecedented for Les. “Connie?” he stuttered.
“My guardian. Connie,” said Finch. She could hear the hurt in her voice when she said the word ‘guardian,’ and she knew he could hear it, too. She hated that he could hear it. But she couldn’t avoid the truth: that he’d left her to live with a stranger so he’d be free to… what? Sing the ‘Wild Rover’ at a Schooner Bum bar in the rare moments he wasn’t out to sea?
“What do you mean she’s gone?” asked Les. He ran his fingers through his hair. His brow wrinkled with fleeting worry. Probably as he anticipated what this situation might require of him. Nothing stressed Les out more than even the slightest assault on his personal freedom. To his ability to do whatever he wanted, whenever he wanted.
Finch’s stomach tightened in a knot. She needed to convince him there was a real problem here, but she was afraid she’d be dismissed like she usually was. By everyone. She’d just stick to the facts.
She took a deep breath. “I came home from school. Connie wasn’t there. There was no note. I made myself dinner. I read a history chapter. She’s still not there,” said Finch as if reciting a grocery list. “I’ve spent all night looking for you.” She paused. She didn’t know why she said the next part, but it spilled out of her mouth nonetheless. Maybe to remind him that she was, technically, a child. A child who needed help. “And now it’s late. It’s eleven. And it’s a school night.”
“How did you find me?” asked Les, clearly still more preoccupied with the obstacle between him and a night of shenanigans than the fact that his sister was alone. Again.
“I looked up things to do in Key West tonight on the internet. This event was called Mari-aoke. Maritime Karaoke.” She paused. “There’s literally nowhere else on the planet you were more likely to be.”
Les chuckled, clearly a little impressed. He raised his eyebrows once—a quick up and down—to signal his concession. “That’s pretty good, Nancy Drew,” he said, his relaxed, swaying torso a stark contrast to Finch’s raised shoulders and balled fists. “Back to the Case of the Missing Foster Mom.”
Finch’s face flushed with hot anger. She knew he would do this. Write her off. Chalk it all up to her trauma, her grief, her—
“I know you’ve been anxious about people leaving you, Finchy,” Les said. “But I think your guardian probably just has a life outside of you. Maybe she forgot to tell you about bingo night or the bowling league. Or maybe she had one too many martinis with Susan and Delores.”
Finch clenched her jaw. Les was trying to call her self-centered now? “You’re just making up old lady names,” said Finch, teeth gritted. “There is no Susan or Delores. And Connie would have told me about bingo night or the bowling league. She probably would have brought me.” Finch’s eyes pricked with tears. She found it both absurd and harrowing that Les was the only person she could turn to. How quickly things could change.
“You get my point, though?” asked Les. His strained tone betrayed his eagerness to be released back into the wild. Into the giant playground of a world he loved to frolic around, unencumbered. “If I walk you home now, she’ll probably be crocheting on the couch with Delores, wondering where the hell you went.”
Finch knew she couldn’t convince him tonight. But she just desperately, deeply, did not want to handle this alone. She’d handled so many things alone already in the last year. She took a deep breath, praying he wouldn’t hear the tearful waver when she spoke. “Can you just… can you stay with me tonight? Please?”
He stood on one foot to scratch his left ankle with the toes of his right sneaker. He didn’t look at her. To his shoes, he said, “Look. I’ll start by walking you home and we’ll assess the situation. Besides, I want to meet this damn Delores I’ve been hearing so much about.” He started off down the sidewalk, Finch scampering along behind him.
“Stop it with Delores,” mumbled Finch. He still thought this was a big game. The Little Orphaned Sister game. Sometimes you had to tuck in the little orphaned sister and say there, there and humor the monsters she imagined in the shadows. But Finch knew she wasn’t the sort to need pandering. She’d survived more in a year than most people could in a lifetime. She knew Connie wouldn’t be there when they got home. And Finch was pretty sure it was because something terrible had happened.